That review isn't terrible really. They do afterall give it a B+ and say that if you can get past some of the repetive aspects you'll find something deeper and interesting. Not everyone will want to look past Yuri's tears and consider the reasonings and raw emotions, most will want their leads to be unshakable and I suppose the review is aimed at a general audience.
My interpretation is that Yuri throughout the series is the only one to consistently show real honest emotions and as if to prove that, she is described as being 'too normal' and is the only one who remains human. Kumi and Kasumi's shocking experiences forcing them to grow up mentally faster than they would normally be expected and making them hide their real feelings of loneliness/depression contrasts with Yuri. On the surface we look at Kasumi and Kumi and think they are the strongest, but deep down they suffer and at one point or another lose sight of themselves to be permanently controlled by aliens until things are righted again. Well thats just my opinion.
I do think it a shame regarding some of the cristicisms, but its a reviewers job to be critical.
I have seen a harsher review. Where they just basically can't get over the fact of Yuri crying so much and find it so ridiculous that they can hardly bare to watch and decide to play target practice at Yuri until it ends.... To each their own I guess.
_________________
- -- ---
Alien 9 / Alien Nine Unofficial Website - Since November 2003 --- -- -